Dutch Pundits Slam Ajax's Goalkeeper Signing as Questionable Move
Dutch football analysts Johan Derksen and René van der Gijp have publicly criticized Ajax's decision to sign goalkeeper Maarten Paes, calling the transfer baffling and labeling the player as fundamentally flawed. Their comments came during a recent episode of the television program Vandaag Inside, where they dissected a specific error from a recent match against FC Twente. The pundits argue that Ajax should have pursued a more experienced option instead of acquiring a goalkeeper they view as inadequate.
The Critical Analysis from Vandaag Inside
During the show, van der Gijp highlighted a moment from Ajax's 1-2 loss to FC Twente in the 86th minute. He pointed out an instance where Paes attempted to clear the ball near the byline but mishandled it by touching it with his standing foot first. "He's wearing gloves for a reason," van der Gijp remarked with a smile, implying that the mistake was basic and avoidable for a professional goalkeeper. This clip served as the focal point for their critique, emphasizing what they see as a lack of fundamental skills.
Derksen echoed these sentiments, bluntly stating, "He's a rubbish keeper." He expressed disbelief at Ajax's recruitment strategy, questioning how the club managed to sign Paes in the first place. According to Derksen, Ajax should have targeted an experienced goalkeeper who was sitting on the bench at another club, rather than opting for a player he deems subpar. He noted that Paes was previously considered insufficient at FC Utrecht, which led to his departure from that team.
Ajax's Goalkeeper Situation and Paes's Background
Ajax signed Maarten Paes from FC Dallas in early February 2026, following Remko Pasveer's move to Heracles Almelo. Paes, an Indonesian international, has since made six appearances for Ajax, keeping two clean sheets in those matches. Despite this, the pundits' criticism centers on his perceived technical flaws and the club's decision-making process. Their analysis suggests that Ajax may have overlooked better options in favor of a signing that has raised eyebrows among experts.
- Transfer Details: Paes joined Ajax from FC Dallas in February 2026.
- Performance Stats: Six appearances with two clean sheets so far.
- Previous Club: He was with FC Utrecht before moving to FC Dallas, where Derksen claims he was viewed as inadequate.
- Replacement Context: His signing came after Remko Pasveer's departure to Heracles Almelo.
Why This Criticism Matters for Ajax
The backlash from Derksen and van der Gijp highlights broader concerns about Ajax's recruitment strategy, especially in a key position like goalkeeper. As a club with a rich history and high expectations, such public criticism from respected figures in Dutch football could impact team morale and fan confidence. It also raises questions about whether Ajax's scouting and transfer policies are aligning with their competitive goals in the Eredivisie and beyond.
Key Takeaways
- Pundit Disapproval: Johan Derksen and René van der Gijp have strongly criticized Ajax's signing of Maarten Paes, calling him a "rubbish keeper."
- Specific Incident: They pointed to a mistake in Ajax's match against FC Twente as evidence of Paes's flaws.
- Transfer Critique: Derksen believes Ajax should have signed an experienced backup goalkeeper instead.
- Player Background: Paes joined from FC Dallas and has made six appearances with two clean sheets.
- Broader Implications: This criticism sheds light on potential issues with Ajax's recruitment strategy.
In summary, the vocal criticism from Dutch football pundits underscores the scrutiny facing Ajax over their goalkeeper signing. While Paes has had some clean sheets, the debate around his abilities and the club's decision-making process continues to stir discussion in the football community.
— Editorial Team
