Steve Nicol’s Liverpool Treasures Head to Auction — FA Cup Medal Could Hit £20K
A piece of Liverpool FC history is about to hit the auction block. Steve Nicol, the legendary Scot who spent 13 years at Anfield, is putting some of his most prized career memorabilia up for sale — including his 1986 FA Cup winner’s medal, which could fetch as much as £20,000.
The auction, hosted by Propstore in London from April 21 to May 14, features over 50 lots tied to Nicol’s decorated playing days. It’s not just Liverpool fans who might be interested — collectors and football historians worldwide are expected to bid on items that span club glory, international duty, and even MLS nostalgia.
What’s Up for Grabs
Nicol’s collection isn’t just random souvenirs — each item tells a story. Here’s what stands out:
- 1986 FA Cup Winner’s Medal — Awarded after Liverpool’s 3-1 win over Everton at Wembley. Estimated value: £10,000–£20,000.
- 1984 European Cup Medal — From the dramatic penalty shootout win against Roma in Rome. Expected to sell for £8,000–£16,000.
- 1989 FWA Footballer of the Year Trophy — Given to him during his peak season. Valued between £2,000–£4,000.
- Match-Worn Shirts — Including the one from the 1989 FA Cup final (vs Everton again) and the Scotland vs England Rous Cup clash in 1988. Prices range from £1,000 to £6,000.
- Signed MLS All-Star Shirt — Featuring autographs from David Beckham and Landon Donovan. Pre-sale estimate: £400–£800.
These aren’t mass-produced collectibles. Each piece comes with documented provenance and personal significance. That’s why Propstore expects fierce bidding — especially on the FA Cup medal, which symbolizes one of Liverpool’s most iconic derby wins.
Why This Matters Beyond Price Tags
Steve Nicol wasn’t just a squad player — he was a versatile, reliable force for Liverpool during their golden era. He played over 450 games, scored 46 goals, and won three FA Cups, five league titles, and a European Cup. His ability to slot into defense or midfield made him indispensable under managers like Kenny Dalglish.
But this auction isn’t just about stats or silverware. It’s about legacy. In interviews, Nicol has said these items hold deep personal meaning — but he’s ready to pass them on to fans who’ll cherish them just as much. “I’ve been fortunate to be part of some incredible teams,” he said. “It means a great deal to know they’ll continue to be appreciated.”
For collectors, owning one of these pieces is like holding a chapter of football history. For Liverpool supporters, it’s a tangible link to the club’s dominance in the 80s — an era defined by grit, flair, and unforgettable moments against rivals like Everton.
The Bigger Picture: Memorabilia Market Trends
Football memorabilia has exploded in value over the last decade. Rare match-worn shirts, signed boots, and original medals from iconic finals now command five-figure sums — sometimes more. Why? Two reasons: scarcity and emotional connection.
Unlike modern merch, older items weren’t produced in bulk. Many were kept privately, lost, or discarded. When something like Nicol’s FA Cup medal surfaces — authenticated and in good condition — it becomes a unicorn.
Also, nostalgia drives demand. Fans who grew up watching Nicol anchor Liverpool’s backline are now in their 40s and 50s, with disposable income and a desire to reconnect with their youth. International collectors, especially in Asia and North America, also see historic English football items as blue-chip investments.
Propstore specialist Alastair McCrea put it best: “Material of this quality and provenance doesn’t come around often.” That’s why estimates are conservative — final bids could easily surpass them.
Key Takeaways
- Steve Nicol’s 1986 FA Cup medal is the crown jewel of this auction, valued up to £20,000.
- The collection spans Liverpool’s golden era, Scotland internationals, and even MLS memorabilia.
- Items include medals, trophies, and match-worn shirts — all authenticated and personally significant.
- Demand will likely exceed estimates due to rarity, emotional value, and global collector interest.
- Nicol hopes the items find homes with passionate fans, not just investors.
This isn’t just an auction — it’s a celebration of one man’s journey through football’s most storied corridors. Whether you’re a Liverpool loyalist, a memorabilia hunter, or just someone who loves the game’s history, Nicol’s collection offers a rare window into football’s past — and its enduring emotional currency.
— Editorial Team
